My boyfriend was supposed to be at his apartment which is roughly an hour away from where I work but he happened to be in the area in the morning so he asked me to get lunch with him. I was ecstatic to say the least. I quickly seized the opportunity to yelp a good lunch restaurant in the area and came up with Spencer’s Bistro.
http://www.yelp.com/biz/spencers-bistro-buena-park-2
It had 4.5 stars out of a good number of reviews and the pictures made the food look pretty appetizing. I thought I had struck food gold.
We pulled into the parking lot of a questionable looking complex and I had a slightly bad feeling. Not that this restaurant is located in a bad part of town…it just wasn’t the part of town I would expect to see an Italian Bistro and next to a laundromat to boot. I was still hopeful though! We walked in and the inside was just as surprising. I don’t know why but I still expected to walk into a sit-down restaurant and was surprised when I saw it was the kind of restaurant where you order at the counter, pay, and then sit down for them to bring your food to you.
To their credit they had three or four large televisions that displayed their menu and various slides of their food. It LOOKED good. I wanted to try everything since we could only eat there once and it was a completely new place!! We ended up ordering:
1) Parmesan French Fries with Garlic Aoli
2) Tomato Soup (which I requested to be more of a Bisque) with a Grilled Cheese
3) Greek Grilled Chicken (which the server convinced me would be much better than the ribs I had wanted to try)
4) Smoked Chicken and Champs (ignoring the fact that neither of us knew what champs were)
We ordered and sat down, excitedly awaiting what this new restaurant would bring us and admiring the interior decorating of the spot. My boyfriend ended up needing to use the bathroom, which curiously enough was located on the outside of the establishment, around the corner, and through the back door of the restaurant. I’m just glad I wasn’t the one that needed to pee–and that it was daytime because that’s just a little bit sketchy.
The fries came out and I was immediately a fan. The quality of the french fries was cooked exactly how I like them. Light and crunchy on the outside but soft and warm on the inside. The Parmesan added a lot of great flavor as well. The garlic aoli didn’t taste like much of anything but it carried a strong essence of garlic which was interesting, but we ended up asking for ketchup.

Parmesan Fries with Garlic Aoli
Next up was the Tomato Soup which looked and tasted more like a paste. It came with two slices of baguette with a layer of mozzarella cheese toasted between them, making a small dipping sandwich. The soup was great to dip the cheesy bread in, but on its own I wouldn’t have liked it. At the very least, presentation was very nice.

Tomato Soup with Grilled Cheese
Not too long after our appetizers were down, our entrees came out. If nothing else, the service was prompt. We didn’t have a painfully long wait to add to our hunger and both our entrees came out together so it wasn’t awkward.
The Greek Grilled Chicken didn’t look too similar to the picture on the menu but was still plated nicely. It didn’t look like there was any tatziki which I expected there to be based both on the picture and the fact that it was Greek Grilled Chicken. It tasted…healthy. Ok, it was bland. Everything in the dish were ingredients that I generally like but this combination and preparation left a lot wanting. The chicken was cooked to an odd consistency. It was both rubbery and tender in a bizarre way and I tried for three mouthfuls to convince myself that I liked it more than I did. I quickly gave up and just kept eating fries.

Greek Grilled Chicken
Next up, the Smoked Chicken. I was glad that was my boyfriend’s order and not mine. The plating was nice but even that didn’t make the food look very appetizing to me. It just looked like shredded cabbage on top of mashed potatoes with chicken somewhere in between on a plate of green sauce. Maybe I just don’t have the refined tastes to appreciate something like that…but I’m okay with that. I sampled a piece of his chicken and it definitely tasted smoked and had that same consistency as my chicken had–not good.

Smoked Mush…I mean Chicken
There were a few awkward minutes after trying our entrees before I finally stated rather than asked that he didn’t like it. He nodded and we agreed to get out of there. I took my food to go because at the very least I hoped my mom could eat it, since she’ll eat pretty much anything if it seems healthy for you. Whether or not she actually did eat it, I don’t know. I just put it on her desk when I got back to work and walked away. I felt really bad about this failed excursion and could not stop apologizing for the failed meal. Thankfully, my boyfriend consoled me and said that he was glad that we at least ventured out and tried something new, even if it wasn’t what we had hoped for. That made me feel better and it reminded me that that was the point of this whole thing. There are probably going to be a lot, a LOT of bad meals but it’s all an experience and the good will outweigh the bad by far more.
I was sorely disappointed by this visit and when walking out I said to my boyfriend, “That is why we don’t try new things.” Alas, I am not to be discouraged and would even be willing to give Spencer’s a second chance, just because everyone deserves one. Thankfully that won’t be possible until 2016. But for all it’s worth, there were a number of other yummy-looking things that I wasn’t fortunate enough to try. So maybe someday in the far, FAR distant future. And I can only hope that this experience was a result of our poor ordering skills or a bad day in the kitchen.
’til next year Spencer’s Bistro! Or maybe the year after…